The Deal Playbook
Private-equity firms do not buy newspapers for journalism. They buy distressed cash flow, pile on debt, harvest fees, and exit before the presses seize. In 2024 hedge funds and PE groups controlled an estimated one-third of U.S. daily circulation, according to the State of Local News report from Northwestern’s Medill School State of Local News 2024.
Step 1: Leverage the Balance Sheet
A fund forms a shell company, borrows against future cash flow, and acquires a cluster of papers. Alden Global Capital used this tactic to pick up Tribune Publishing in 2021, adding 9 metros to a portfolio that already held 68 dailies and 300+ weeklies What Works News Coverage. The debt sits on the newspapers; the fund collects a management fee.
Step 2: Consolidate, Cut, Centralize
Costs fall fastest where citizens feel it most: reporters. Median newsroom headcount at Alden papers dropped 55 percent between 2012 and 2022, versus a 33 percent industry drop Hedged. Printing plants close, customer service moves offshore, copyediting shifts to a hub two time zones away.
Step 3: Milk the Margin
With debt serviced and payroll slashed, cash still flows—until it doesn’t. Funds dividend out what remains. A 2023 Boston Globe review found Alden siphoned $300 million from MediaNews Group through “consulting fees” and real-estate deals over ten years.
Charlotte Case Study: The Chatham Pivot
McClatchy’s 2020 bankruptcy put The Charlotte Observer on the block. Chatham Asset Management, a New Jersey hedge fund, won the auction and converted $263 million of debt into ownership Axios Charlotte. Newsroom jobs fell from 210 (2009) to about 65 (2024); print home delivery shrank to three days per week. The city of 880,000 now relies on a skeleton daily and a patchwork of niche sites.
The Civic Ledger
- 2,500 U.S. newspapers have closed since 2005, a quarter of the market Washington Post.
- 279 counties now have zero or one local outlet, classified as “high-risk news deserts” AP News.
- Municipal borrowing costs rise 5–10 basis points in counties losing a daily, evidence that less scrutiny equals pricier bonds (Brookings, 2023).
Why Advertisers Should Care
When reporting disappears, so do engaged readers. Page views sink, ad impressions decline, and brands chase eyeballs elsewhere. A 2024 Poynter survey of regional businesses found 61 percent cut spending with chain papers after seeing local beats eliminated by Poynter. PE owns the asset; you own the wasted budget.
The Exit—and the Wreckage
Funds flip real estate, merge titles, or liquidate mastheads. Communities inherit a “ghost paper”—a familiar logo carrying wire copy and sponsored obituaries. Trust erodes; civic turnout falls; corruption climbs. PE profits are internalized, public costs externalized. Classic tragedy of the commons, played out on newsprint.
Opening for Public-Benefit Models
The gap is large, but so is the opportunity. Independent, privacy-first outlets—yes, we have skin in that game—can reclaim beats abandoned by leveraged chains. Clean balance sheets, diversified revenue, and open licensing keep cash in the newsroom, not the Caymans.
About the Author
Fueled by an espresso that might qualify as a controlled substance, Peter Cellino scribbles about journalism’s money trail. Ping him on Bluesky @pc51.bsky.social and wander the Mercury Local rabbit hole: Blog | Case Studies | Resources | Local SEO Playbook | Advertising | Charlotte Mercury | Strolling Ballantyne.
Footnotes & Fine Print
Enjoy the read? Peruse our policies and ping us anytime: Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | About Us | Contact
Creative Commons License
© 2025 Mercury Local / Mercury Local
This article, “How Private Equity Gutted Local Newspapers: A Data-Driven Autopsy,” by Peter Cellino is licensed under CC BY-ND 4.0.
“How Private Equity Gutted Local Newspapers: A Data-Driven Autopsy”
by Peter Cellino, Mercury Local (CC BY-ND 4.0)
